37 Percent of Americans Think They're Too Broke to Save
By Morgan Quinn, Feature Writer
Americans really want to save. They just don’t know if they can do it.
Saving money is this year’s most popular financial resolution, with more than 37 percent of Americans prioritizing it over paying down debt, curbing their spending, investing and even getting a raise. But a new GOBankingRates survey, which asked consumers about their biggest savings goals for 2015, found nearly one in four respondents aren’t at all confident that they’ll be able to meet this resolution.
The poll revealed Americans’ No. 1 short- and long-term savings goals, the biggest obstacles they believe are keeping them from success, and what they’re planning on doing differently in 2015 to save more.
Overall, building an emergency savings account came in first place for short-term savings goals, while saving for retirement was the most popular long-term goal. Insufficient income was the top response for the biggest obstacle facing savers in 2015, followed by unemployment; more than 22 percent of respondents said they have little or no confidence they’ll be able to follow through on their savings resolution this year.
There were some surprising variations among demographics. For example, women are more focused on building an emergency fund, while men are far more likely to be saving for a vehicle. Millennials also have cars on their minds, as well as big-ticket items and vacations, whereas Gen Xers are pursuing homeownership and baby boomers are busy saving for home renovations and retirement.
Related: Study Finds More People Are Afraid of Going Broke Than Dying
Click for high-resolution version.
Share this infographic on your blog or website and tell us your thoughts. Just copy and paste this code snippet
Please include attribution to GOBankingRates.com with this graphic.
Find the best bank rates at GOBankingRates.com.
What Americans Are Saving for in 2015
Top Short-Term Savings Goals
Note that due to rounding, figures do not add up to 100 percent.
Top Long-Term Savings Goals
|Retirement health care costs||19.60%|
|Having a family||8.66%|
The Gender Divide
For their short-term financial goals, men are approximately 50 percent more likely than women to be saving for a vehicle, while women are 16 percent more likely to be saving for an emergency fund. As for long-term financial goals, women are 40 percent more likely to be saving for retirement health care costs, while men are more likely to be saving for a family and education — roughly 30 and 26 percent more, respectively.
The Conflicting Priorities of Millennials
The 18- to 24 year-olds surveyed listed saving for a vehicle as their top short-term goal far more than any other group. The other most common savings goals for this age group were building an emergency fund and planning a vacation. Of all the respondents, 24- to 34-year-olds were more than twice as likely to be saving for a wedding.
Saving for a family was the top long-term goal among 18 -to 24-year-olds, but this age group was the least likely to be saving for retirement or an emergency fund. Millennials were also the least likely to list paying down debt as something they will do differently to achieve their savings goals, despite one in 10 citing loans as their biggest obstacle to saving. That said, given millennials are the most likely to be struggling with unemployment, low wages and student loans, they might not feel they have the extra funds needed to tackle debt.
Related: 7 Money Myths About Millennials
Generation X: The Struggle to Settle Down
Among those surveyed, 25- to 44-year olds were most likely of any age group to list homeownership as their top long-term savings goal, followed by saving for a family.
For short-term goals, this group was the most likely of any age bracket to be saving for a wedding. Meanwhile, 35- to 44-year-olds were most concerned with building an emergency fund.
Baby Boomers: Preparing for the Future
45- to 64-year-olds were the most likely of any age group to be saving short-term for home renovations or repairs.
Among all respondents, there was a strong correlation between age and likelihood to select retirement health care costs or retirement as a long-term savings goal. Those 45 and older named saving for retirement and retirement health care costs as their top long-term savings goals; respondents 65 and older were most likely to be saving for both categories, while 18- to 24-year-olds were the least likely.
Following the Money: Income and Savings Goals
Income and saving for a big-ticket purchase or a vacation are positively correlated: The more money you make, the more likely it is that you’ll be saving up for a big purchase or that trip to the Bahamas.
It comes as no surprise that those with the two highest income brackets are least likely to be saving for an emergency fund, while the lowest income bracket is most likely to have this goal. This remained the biggest concern across all income brackets except those earning $150,000 plus a year, who were more concerned with saving for a vacation.
Saving for retirement and retirement health care costs positively correlates with income; as the respondent’s salary increases, so does the likelihood that he will be saving for one of the retirement goals.
Additionally, those with the lowest and highest income brackets are both the most likely to be saving for a family.
The Biggest Obstacles to Saving in 2015
|Poor money management||10.75%|
|Credit card debt||9.55%|
|No bank account||1.19%|
Even though insufficient income was the most popular obstacle to saving in 2015, unemployment was the most consistent factor across all age groups. Among 18- to 24-year-olds, 25- to 34-year-olds and 55- to 64-year-olds, about one in nine respondents named unemployment as their biggest obstacle.
Men vs. Women: Women were more likely to list unemployment and insufficient income as their biggest obstacles, while men were more likely to choose poor money management.
Millennials: Unemployment was the top obstacle among 18-to 34-year olds, but they were also more likely than any other age group to cite poor money management as a problem. Those 34 and under were also the most likely to cite loans as an obstacle to saving, likely due to student debt.
Gen X: Insufficient income was the top obstacle for this age group, consistent with overall results. Gen Xers were also more likely than their younger and retired counterparts to mention credit card debt.
Baby Boomers: Those aged 55 to 64 were most likely of any group to list unemployment as the top obstacle, followed by insufficient income and credit card debt.
How Confident Are Americans That They’ll Meet Their Savings Goals?
|Not very confident||17.31%|
|Not confident at all||4.98%|
Most respondents, almost 54 percent, feel “somewhat confident” in their ability to reach their savings goals in 2015. A third (34 percent) feel “extremely confident.” Only 5 percent said they were “not confident at all,” while more (17 percent) said they were “not very confident” that they could reach their 2015 savings goals.
What They’ll Do Differently to Achieve Their Goals
|Budget more effectively||43.58%|
|Pay down debt||23.38%|
|Contribute to a retirement savings account||9.75%|
|Consult professional advice (advisor, books, blogs, etc.)||4.38%|
|Open a bank account or get a better bank account||3.78%|
|I won’t do anything differently||15.12%|
Note that due to rounding, figures do not add up to 100 percent.
When asked what they planned to do differently in 2015 to achieve their goals, the most common response was to budget more effectively, with 43 percent of respondents giving this answer. The next most popular response was paying down debt (23 percent); 15 percent said they didn’t have plans to make changes in the new year.
GOBankingRates conducted a Survata survey from Dec. 3 to 11, 2014, which polled 1,006 respondents, all of whom confirmed having a savings goal for 2015 before being asked questions regarding their savings habits and goals.
Photo credit: Erica Minton